I must say Karen Hayden was very good at keeping me informed and I received a very pleasing outcome.
Mrs P.M. Ratcliffe
Donor Organ Transplant Dangers
Wed 24th Aug 2011 Clinical negligence
I was horrified to read in the Guardian that two people were given kidney transplants from a donor who had a rare and aggressive form of cancer.
I thought that multiple tests were performed and
relatives consent obtained before a transplant could take case. It is
frightening to read that this cancer was not identified before the transplant
surgery. Both recipients had to go through six cycles of chemotherapy. Luckily,
they are both clear at the present time.
James Neuberger, NHS Blood and Transplant (NHSBT)'s associate medical director, said: "NHSBT has had discussions with medical directors at both the donor and recipient hospitals about this situation. Whilst we are pleased to hear that the patients involved in this situation have had a positive response to their treatment we are keen to put in place measures to ensure this does not happen again. We are currently finalising a number of recommendations, including improving communication among specialist nurses, organ donation, recipient transplant co-ordinators and surgeons."
Guidance to clinicians on obtaining consent from patients and warning them of risks – including from donor-donated tumours – was already being prepared before the incidents and has now been circulated. NHSBT is also compiling a register of such incidents, and further advice will be issued after the Liverpool case.
James Neuberger said "a transplant may be the only possible treatment for some people, who would die without one. In a situation where there are not nearly enough organs available for the number of transplants required, it often comes down to a balance of risk and benefit. Guidance is available that sets out the risks and benefits of when an organ should be used. Ultimately this is a decision for the clinician, the patient and their family."
What a relief for these two people. It is appreciated that a balance has to be struck between the need of the recipient and the shortage of donor organs; however, checks certainly need to be put in place to ensure that this does not happen again.
Solicitor - Clinical Negligence Team.
Would you like us to call you back?
Call us between 8am and 6pm Monday to Friday, or use the enquiry form outside office hours
Or call us on 0844 620 6600